Meemaw’s gonna lose her teeth over this’un 😂


2ND EDITION | ISSUE #151

I can smell it like it was yesterday.

The pine pulp and paper mill outside the city, while we sat in the rocking chairs outside.

The faint smell of cigarettes and haze from the smoking section.

I searched the walls around me for little treasures. Nostalgic things I thought were cool.

My dad and I had spent the last 20 minutes playing peg solitaire, and like a mirage the server came out with my favorite meal steaming from a tray - Chicken and dumplings.

I can taste the pepper and gravy right now.

It was the early 2000’s somewhere in North Carolina at a cracker barrel.

A simpler time.

A time of kitschy toys in the gift shop and rock candy suckers.

And a time before the Cracker Barrel rebrand that caught the country by storm.

A 700 million dollar rebrand so that was so ill received that the restaurant decided to revert.

But why was this rebrand so bad after all?

Could removing some dude named ‘uncle hershel’ from a logo really be that big of a deal?

How can a simple rebrand result in resulting in a loss of nearly $100 million in market value after its stock plunged.

Users on Reddit (and all over the internet for that matter) certainly had something to say…

But i think it is the co-founder of the brand who said it best

“They’re trying to modernize to be like the competition — Cracker Barrel doesn’t have any competition

Tommy Lowe, co-founder of the first Cracker Barrel in 1969, slammed the rebrand as “pitiful,” saying Masino didn’t understand Cracker Barrel’s identity because of her background in fast food.

“Spending $700 million doing that is throwing money out the window,” he said.

It wasn’t because they removed some random guy from the logo.

It was because it no longer felt personal.

Cracker Barrel's differentiators are that

  • You want to take your time to experience it, play the game at your table, enjoy a fire next to the hearth, and play checkers or wander the store. It is more than a restaurant or a country store - it's an experience.
  • The brand screams nostalgia and stories - I can remember like yesterday my little sister begging for a sticker doll book. My grandma loved the rockers so much - we chipped in as a family and got her a set for Christmas one year. We spent so many summer Sunday nights on those rockers on her porch. They’ve been in great shape for 15 years.

They aren’t fast food. And instead of leaning into the things that made them different. They tried to modernize.

In a world that is sick of AI.

In a world that is sick of neutral interiors, whitewashing, and millennial gray.

In a world that spends a lot of time on screens, stressed, and missing times that felt simpler.

They could have leaned into the personal feeling. But instead, they leaned out and paid for it.

Just because a framework works for you, "competition" doesn't mean it will work for you. Listening to your audience and understanding how they perceive you & your brand should be the first step you take, whether you are rebranding, repositioning, or just pivoting your brand.

As far as Cracker Barrel goes...

Here’s a designer on the gram who I think could have done a lot better

And here's a genius way they could respond to this PR nightmare

If you’re prepping for a rebrand - here’s how to avoid a rebrand fail like Cracker Barrel ↓

If there is one thing I could scream from the rooftops, it would be capitalizing on your differentiators. I prefer to say 'brand positioning' over 'niching down.

Understanding not just what you think your audience wants—but how they actually perceive you (which is the exact definition of brand positioning) is the most important thing you can do if you want your marketing and your brand to land and convert with your customers.

Research of all kinds, from polling to research calls, is the first thing I do when I am first refreshing Cedar June—and when I am working with a brand.

Here's a free Notion template you can download, complete with all my tips inside.

  • Whether it's analyzing your feedback & reviews (you can use your robot friends to help with this),
  • Conducting research calls (hands down one of the most valuable things you can do),
  • Or a combination of the two (the crème de la crème if you ask me).

***Understanding how the audience you have now perceives you is the most useful thing you can do—even if you want to attract a different audience, or expand the audience you have now.

In Cracker Barrel's case, they wanted to rebrand in an effort to attract more diners.

What they should have done is first understood why people love Cracker Barrel—and then create brand stories, marketing, and branding that would attract those who might consider other options.

You want more young people coming out? Remind them of the summer evening they spent there rocking outside while waiting for a table with their grandma—show them how their kids could have the viral "90's summer" everyone has been posting about—inside their restaurant and store.

One of the biggest misconceptions about rebranding IMO is that everything needs to change. When in reality, there are probably some things about your brand that already work & are recognized and associated with your branding.

One of the biggest faux pas of the Cracker Barrel rebranding is the oversimplification of the barrel. Turning it into an icon of sorts. They kept some of their colors, but the addition of black, white, and gray interiors makes it feel stark.

Design is a visual language. It is meant to elicit emotion - take the emotion out, take the personality out - and you are left with just another CEO coded canvas corp.

Nostalgia never goes out of style.

Especially in a time where people are more and more nostalgic for the way things used to be.

There are two ways to roll out a rebrand. By building in public (like I have for the last year) or by doing a full unveil. And honestly, I don't know that there is a wrong or right answer.

When it comes to building in public, you constantly receive feedback from your audience and involve them in the conversation along the way. But where that can get sticky is in the timeline. Rebrands and repositioning — take time. If you are rolling it out over time, it is easy for the conversation to get drawn out and become stale.

The grand unveil can create a lot of noise — but at the same time, you really don't know how it is going to be perceived until you press publish on your post.

I think a hybrid approach is your best bet. Do your research, ask questions, tell people about what you are doing, and open the conversation to the world. Show them sneak peeks along the way, share what you are doing, why you are doing it, and give them sneak peeks of sorts. But save something for the grand unveil.

That's what I'll be doing with my website, for example. I'm going to take you through the process in an Instagram series — but use the launch of that site as the grand unveil.


Watching

I've been watching "World's Greatest Palaces" on Amazon and noticed how surprisingly modern many castles were.

The wealthy elite were early adopters of electricity and modern heating. Yet their design choices still favored traditional aesthetics, hiding modern amenities behind medieval-inspired facades.

Their legacy was tied to history, so they showcased that heritage while incorporating modern innovations behind the scenes. Modernization itself isn't wrong, but Cracker Barrel's identity was in their nostalgic look - that shouldn't have been changed.

Listening

I'm off to see one of my favorite bands, The Lumineers, tonight, so they've been on repeat to "get ready".

Does anyone else do that - listen to the artist they are about to go see on repeat before the show?

I plan to plop my butt on a blanket and have a very chill Wednesday night.

You can listen in on the playlist here

Promoting

If you still need some help with the strategic side of your rebrand, you can book a 60-minute Studio Session for $60 off.

If you need some help with the identity side of your rebrand, I have four spots left this year in my 'Brand Brushstrokes-Done for You' brand identity offer.

And if it's time to roll out the big unveil on your rebrand, there's still time this year to book a Signature Site project.

Not sure where to start? ook a disco call, and we can talk 1:1 about what your brand needs right now.

231 Exchange Street, Attica, NY 14011
Unsubscribe · Preferences

The Weekly Drop In

I'm a Brand strategist & designer helping multi-passionate entrepreneurs build brands that look like them while being strategic enough to scale. Fine arts background, eldest daughter energy, and a firm believer that brands take way longer than a week to build.

Read more from The Weekly Drop In

2ND EDITION | ISSUE #152 These days, friends call me “Catie Pinterest” -specifically, by my one best friend, Jason “Mary with a C” - a play on the fact that my name is, in fact, not Catie but MaryAnd “Marty” - a play on Mary with a C/inside joke that has morphed into a nickname all its ownBack in 2009, I had a nickname that was not *so* different. A nickname that at the time I hated. Martha. Inspired by the one and only, Martha Stewart.Now, my friends were not trying to be mean -and I knew...

2ND EDITION | ISSUE #150 I wear my heart on my sleeve and my emotions on my face (and so does my little sister, if you zoom in on the picture below). This was the moment that my first bridal appointment turned to disappointment. I had been looking forward to this moment since the days of eating cereal at our kitchen countertop and watching Say Yes To The Dress with my mom on our little black box TV. I wanted happy tears. I wanted to leave with a contender I could come back for with my moms. I...

2ND EDITION | ISSUE #149 Mid-set, I felt a tap on my shoulder. Next to me - a fellow concert lean in. She pointed at my old, scuffed and dirty cowboy boots and yelled over the band (we were in the second row) “Those are Awesome! If those boots could tell stories - you’d be in jail”. My new favorite compliment of all time. And honestly, she isn’t wrong. If those boots could talk - they could tell you about the time I snuck into the pit at Craig Morgan the day after my 18th birthday, and then...